1993 - 1995 Digital HDTV Grand Alliance Development

Formation of the Grand Alliance

Jan-April 1993 – Competitive activities proceed at NAB 93 as each proponent makes system improvements and contemplates re-testing of improved systems

 

March 1993 – With FCC Advisory Committee (ACATS) encouragement, discussions begin amidst Industry speculation

                             Broadcasting & Cable  |   Multichannel News  

 

April 12, 1993  – Plans are finalized for Technical discussions

 

April 14-15, 1993  Grand Alliance Technical Meetings are held

May 11, 1993 - ATRC proposes details of Grand Alliance video compression tests 

 

May 20, 1993 - Final discussions take place 

May 24, 1993 - Digital HDTV Grand Alliance is formed. (WSJ  and NYT press coverage)

June 2, 1993 -  A first explanation of the Grand Alliance agreement and working process

Designing and Building the "Best-of-the Best"

Oct 21, 1993 – Key technical decisions are announced.  MPEG compression (including B-frames), MPEG packet transport. Comparative testing results in the selection of Dolby’s AC-3 audio subsystem

Jan 1994 – Comparative laboratory testing of Zenith's VSB hardware and General Instrument's QAM hardware results in the selection of Zenith’s VSB transmission subsystem

 

Feb 1, 1994 - A Grand Alliance status report (Glenn Reitmeier, Sarnoff/Thomson report) provides context on ACATS history, Grand Alliance  organization and its anticipated schedule.

The Grand Alliance  organization chart  shows the key role of the Technical Oversight Group (TOG) and the various Technical Experts Groups on Format, Compression, Transport, Transmission, Audio, Systems and Interoperability. 

 

Technical decisions often had ramifications across multiple Expert Groups and they were adjudicated by the TOG, which came to a consensus on all key technical decisions

The Public Relations Group  became the Communications Strategy Group (CSG), which charted the course of the alliance and its drive to establish a digital HDTV standard.  The CSG was chaired by Bruce Allan (Thomson) and included Robert Graves (AT&T), Glenn Reitmeier (Sarnoff), John Taylor (Zenith) and Alan Schlosser  (consultant).

1994 – Design and construction of Grand Alliance prototype hardware begins: Video Compression Encoder (AT&T), Data Packet Encoder (Sarnoff), Data Packet decoder (Thomson), Video Decoder (Philips) and Video Format Converter (AT&T and Sarnoff). System Integration will be performed at Sarnoff.

March 20, 1994 - The Grand Alliance reports on its progress at NAB (the National Association of Broadcasters annual convention

      Grand Alliance planning:  GA NAB94 plan  |  GA Q&A prep

      "Pardon Our Dust - System Under Construction" sign

      Interoperability Aspects of the Grand Alliance HDTV System, Glenn Reitmeier, Sarnoff

      Grand Alliance Video Compression System

      Grand Alliance HDTV Audio Subsystem - Dolby AC-3, Craig Todd (Dolby)

      Grand Alliance Transmission System - VSB,  Wayne Luplow (Zenith)

      Grand Alliance HDTV Video Formats,  Bob Keeler (AT&T)

       NAB 94 Grand Alliance Press Releases

 

The Press Releases provide excellent background and context. They optimistically predict that the standard will be set in 1995 and that receivers could go on sale as early as late 1996.  [The ATSC standard was indeed set in Sept 1995;  Controversy and politics delayed FCC approval until late 1996 and consequently the first consumer receivers became available in early 1998]

April 14, 1994 - Grand Alliance System Description v1 documentation is completed and submitted to ACATS

 

April 19, 1994 - The ACATS Technical Subgroup Master Calender is revised.  Testing of the Grand Alliance prototype system was targeted for Nov. 1994 and the completion of all testing and reports by Mar 31, 1995 [Ironically, this was the date that the Grand Alliance actually shipped its two prototypes for testing and to it's world premiere demonstration at NAB 95]

May 10-11, 1994 – NIST Digital Video Workshop is held to "highlight technical issues for industry and government decision makers with respect to advanced digital video (ADV) in the National Information Infrastructure (NII)…"  The Grand Alliance system is a key element of the workshop.  The Workshop Report states that "The Grand Alliance proposal for digital, terrestrial broadcast of HDTV incorporates several features to achieve interoperability with NII-type services..."  but it marked the beginning of growing opposition from the computer industry

 

July 1-14, 1994 - Work is in progress among Grand Alliance members to lock down the prototype hardware construction schedule.   As the hardware architecture and interfaces become more defined, more realistic planning moves the estimated start of testing from mid-November 1994 to late January 1995.  The additional requirement of a very high quality 1080i to/from 720 format converter (by AT&T and Sarnoff) had been a previously unplanned task. 

 

Sept 23, 1994 - After a period of conceptualization and planning its key messages for various industry and government stakeholders, the final version of the Grand Alliance Washington Demonstration script is agreed upon, and production begins.

    Watch the Grand Alliance Washington Demonstration Video

Dec 7, 1994 - Grand Alliance System Description v2 documentation is completed and submitted to ACATS.  This document became the basis for the ATSC Digital Television standard

Dec 1994 - John Taylor (Zenith) reports the Grand Alliance's progress in the IEEE Consumer Electronics Society Newsletter

System Integration

Jan - March 1995 – Ongoing system integration at Sarnoff’s Field Lab. 

Sarnoff leads system integration of the subsystems built by various Grand Alliance member and partner companies: 

     - Video Format Converter (Sarnoff and AT&T)

     - Video Compression Encoder (AT&T and General Instrument)

     - Audio Compression Encoder (Dolby)

     - Packet Data Encoder (Sarnoff)

     - 8-VSB Transmission and Reception (Zenith)

     - Packet Data Receiver (Thomson)

     - Video Decoder (Philips)

     - Audio Decoder (Dolby)

 

March 30, 1995 – System integration at Sarnoff’s Field Lab is completed. 

March 31, 1995 - the two prototype hardware systems are shipped.  One was delivered to the Advanced Television Test Center and the other was sent to the Grand Alliance booth at the NAB convention for its world premiere demonstration.

                                       Photos  (more below)                                     |                                         Behind-the Scenes Video

Grand Alliance Technical Leaders Complete System Integration at Sarnoff's Field Lab - March  30, 1995

Wayne Luplow (Zenith), Glenn Reitmeier (Sarnoff), 

Bob Rast (GI),  Terry Smith (Sarnoff)

Ralph Cerbone (AT&T), Jae Lim (MIT), Aldo Cugnini (Philips)

GA team in Field Lab (300)

GA Tech Leaders Luplow, Reitmeier, Rast, Smith Cerbone, Lim, Cugnini

GA Terry Glenn

Terry Smith and Glenn Reitmeier (Sarnoff)

GA Terry Glenn Hi5

Terry and Glenn Hi5

GA_Field_Lab01

GA_Field_Lab02

GA_Field_Lab07

Paul Lyons and Vic D'Allesandro (Sarnoff)

GA_Field_Lab_11

Paul Lyons and Vic D'Allesandro (Sarnoff)

GA_Field_Lab_10

Jim Carnes and Terry Smith (Sarnoff)

GA_Field_Lab08

Paul Lyons and GA Transport Packet Rack

GA_Field_Lab06

Smith, Carnes, Lyons, Reitmeier

GA_Field_Lab05

Carnes, Smith, Reitmeier

GA_Field_Lab04

Jim Carnes (Sarnoff)

GA_Field_Lab03

GA Hardware

GA_Field_Lab09

Sarnoff Engineers

GA_Field_Lab_12

GA Hardware

GA_Field_Lab_13

GA Hardware

World Premiere at NAB 95

April 9, 1995 - NAB Engineering conference features a special session with Grand Alliance, ATSC and ACATS speakers

   

               Richard Wiley (ACATS Chairman)   |  audio  

   

               Jae Lim (GA/MIT)  |  audio

   

               Wayne Luplow (GA/Zenith)  |  audio

   

               Glenn Reitmeier (GA/Sarnoff)  presentation  |  audio

   

               Peter Symes (Grass Valley) |  audio

   

               Peter Fannon (ATTC)  |  audio

   

               Q&A part 1  |audio

   

               Bob Hopkins (ATSC)  |  audio

   

               John Abel (NAB)   |  audio

   

               Joe Flaherty (ACATS) presentation  |  audio

   

               Saul Shapiro (FCC)  presentation  |  audio

   

               Mike Sherlock (Broadcasters' Caucus / NBC)   |  audio

   

                Q&A part 2   audio 

08 - Bob Hopkins
00:00 / 00:00
01 - Richard Wiley
00:00 / 00:00
02 - Jae Lim (MIT)
00:00 / 00:00
03 - Wayne Luplow (GA/Zenith)
00:00 / 00:00
04 - Glenn Reitmeier (GA/Sarnoff)
00:00 / 00:00
05 - Peter Symes (Grass Valley)
00:00 / 00:00
06 - Peter Fannon (ATTC)
00:00 / 00:00
07 Q&A Session #1 - All
00:00 / 00:00
09 - John Abel (NAB)
00:00 / 00:00
10 - Joe Flaherty (ACATS/CBS)
00:00 / 00:00
11 - Saul Shapiro (FCC)
00:00 / 00:00
12 - Mike Sherlock (Broadcasters Caucus/NBC)
00:00 / 00:00
13 - Q&A Session #2 - All
00:00 / 00:00

April 10, 1995 – The Grand Alliance HDTV system makes its world premiere demonstration at NAB95

The Grand Alliance Booth at NAB95  

The Digital HDTV Grand Alliance Booth at NAB95 featured an inner theater with large-screen projection display.  A demonstration video was shown, processed by the prototype hardware system in real-time.  There were also four demonstration kiosks in the outside area.

The booth's "eye candy" was a 1934 Packard

(quite a paradox for the ultimate in TV technology)

The booth showcased the Grand Alliance prototype hardware (behind glass - note the power cables)

Carlo Basile, Aldo Cugnini  and Tom Patton (Philips) with the Grand Alliance prototype MPEG-2 decoder

The four "kiosk" areas demonstrated key features and capabilities of the Grand Alliance HDTV system

        Digital HDTV Picture Quality         |  Digital HD and SD Picture Quality   | Packetized Data Flexible Use |    Interactive Advertising

Glenn

Reitmeier

(Sarnoff)

Pallavi Shah (Sarnoff)

The World Premiere Demonstration and Press Conference

The Grand Alliance World Premiere Demonstration Audience

Press Conference Part 1 - Jim Carnes (Sarnoff) 

Press Conference Part 2 - Jerry Pearlman (Zenith)

Grand Alliance Q&A Session

Jae Lim (MIT), Glenn Reitmeier (Sarnoff), Carlo Basile (Philips), Ralph Cerbone (AT&T), Bruce Allan (Thomson), Bob Rast (GI), Jerry Pearlman (Zenith), Jim Carnes (Sarnoff)

  Q1: HDTV price?                                |            Q2: Schedule and OFDM?       |         Q3:  Separate Receivers and Displays?

                                      Q4: Content Delivery and Production?   |  Q5: Formats, ATSC and other standards?

Q6:  FCC Approval and Spectrum Auctions?  |                  Q7: Licensing?                  |            Q8: Launch Strategy? - Satellite?

                                    Q9:  Launch Plan? Roadshows?                |                 Q10: Standard Definition Formats?

Demonstration and Booth Tour for FCC Chairman Hundt

Demo for FCC Chairman Hundt, with Reitmeier, Carnes and Basile

Glenn Reitmeier, Reed Hundt, Saul Shapiro,

Blair Levin, Bob Rast, Jerry Pearlman

Bruce Allan, Reed Hundt, Glenn Reitmeier, Joel Brinkley

Jim Carnes, Jerry Pearlman, Reed Hundt, Glenn Reitmeier

April 10, 1995 - More Photos of the Grand Alliance HDTV System at NAB 1995

GA booth1

Grand Alliance booth at NAB 95

Ga booth2

Grand Alliance prototype hardware (note power lines)

95 GA QA

GA Q&A

GA HD display

GA HD display

GA005

GA HDTV vs NTSC

GA HDTV vs NTSC

95-04-02 Glenn Flexible Use Demo

Glenn Reitmeier, Sarnoff - Flexible Channel Use Demo

GA007

Pallavi Shah, Sarnoff Interactive Ad Demo

95-04 GA Interactive Ad screenshot1

Interactive Ad demo screenshot1

GA006

Pallavi Shah, Sarnoff - Interactive Ad demo2

95-04 GA Interactive Ad screenshot2

Interactive Ad demo screenshot2

GA demo station

GA Philips gang

Grand Alliance Debuts Digital HDTV System

 

Grand Alliance Interactive Advertising Demo

Grand Alliance Nearing the Finish Line

Toward A New Era of Television in North America

Grand Alliance HDTV A Key Enabling Technology for the NII

Grand Alliance Supported By Transmitter Manufacturers

Key Technical Elements of the Grand Alliance HDTV System

1995-04-10 Grand Alliance Toward A New E
1995-04-10 Grand Alliance Nearing the Fi
1995-04-10 Grand Alliance HDTV A Key Ena
1995-04-10 Grand Alliance HDTV Interacti
1995-04-10 Grand Alliance Key Technical
1995-04-10 Grand Alliance Supported By T

Testing and Evaluation

April - August, 1995 – The Grand Alliance HDTV system is tested at the ATTC (Advanced Television Test Center) and ATEL (Advanced Television Evaluation Laboratory)

July 19, 1995 - With the goal to finalize a complete digital HDTV standard based on the Grand Alliance system, ACATS and ATSC start to make technical decisions on issues that are outside the scope of the Grand Alliance itself, such as standard definition video formats. 

 

April - September, 1995 – It becomes obvious that Standard Definition video formats can and should be added to the Grand Alliance System.  Considered "out of scope" by MIT, Grand Alliance members work with other industry representative in the ATSC to debate the merits of various proposed formats and to reach consensus

Sept. 16, 1995 – the A/53 ATSC Digital Television Standard is completed.  ATSC standardizes the 1080i and 720p square pixel HDTV formats of the Grand Alliance and also includes standard definition 480p and 480i formats, including both square and rectangular pixel options.

 

Oct 4, 1995 - ATSC also publishes a companion A/54 Guide to the Use of the ATSC Digital Television Standard

 

Oct 31, 1995 – ACATS Technical Subcommittee meets for a final review of test results for the Grand Alliance system

                      Summaries of:   ATTC test results  |  ATEL Test results  |  CableLabs test results

 

The ACATS Technical Subcommittee issues its Final Technical Report, concluding:

    "1. the Grand Alliance system meets the Committee’s performance objectives and is better than any of the four original digital ATV systems

      2. the Grand Alliance system is superior to any known alternative system; and

      3. the ATSC Digital Television Standard, based on the Advisory Committee design specifications and Grand Alliance system, fulfills the                    requirements for the U.S. ATV broadcasting standard.

      Accordingly, the Technical Subgroup recommends that the ATSC Standard be adopted as the U.S. ATV broadcasting standard."

Nov. 11, 1995 – In response to rising objections from the computer industry about interoperability between HDTV and computers, the Grand Alliance stages an extensive interoperability demonstration of live video from camera and computer sources over ATM network  links, satellite and terrestrial broadcast at the MSTV Advanced Television Update.  Although low power, this is the world's first live broadcast of an ATSC signal.

           Grand Alliance Update (Rast),   |   Interoperability Demonstration (Reitmeier)Top 10 HDTV Myths (Perlman)     

       

 Interoperability Demonstration Slides and Grand Alliance Encoding Hardware Tour at Sarnoff (Reitmeier)

 

Nov 28, 1995 – ACATS issues its Final Report and  Recommendation that the FCC adopt the ATSC standard. (ACATS Press Release)

Nov 30, 1995 – The Grand Alliance demonstrates its system for Congress Members and staff on Capitol Hill

 

Dec 20, 1995 – ATSC approves the A/52 standard that documents the Dolby AC-3 audio system

 

GA_Field_Lab_11

Paul Lyons and Vic D'Allesandro (Sarnoff)